Rating · checked November 16, 2026

GEO platform rating 2026: 6 tools scored on 16 criteria.

Humanswith.ai ranks first with 15.5 of 16 points, followed by AthenaHQ (10.5) and Otterly.AI (10). Engine coverage is close across the field. The gap opens after measurement: checking the full buyer conversation, shipping finished articles, publishing them, and running ads inside AI answers.

Disclosure.

Humanswith.ai is our platform and it is in this rating. That is why every competitor score links to a public source with a check date, and where we fall short (Claude is only on a custom plan, there are no dialect tracks in Arabic) we score ourselves accordingly.


Result

Ranked by total points across all four groups.

  1. 1 Humanswith.ai · our platform 15.5 of 16 Birdview PSA case: 0.9% to 21.5% in ChatGPT in 8 weeks. Full cycle: tracking, 5-turn buyer dialogs, 1–40 finished articles a month, publishing and ChatGPT Ads. From $149/month.
  2. 2 AthenaHQ 10.5 of 16 Broad engine coverage with a content optimization agent and published pricing.
  3. 3 Otterly.AI 10 of 16 Affordable monitoring with per-engine add-ons priced in public; audits, no article writing.
  4. 4 Peec AI 9.5 of 16 Clean tracking dashboard; Claude on Enterprise, Copilot via Bing AI Mode.
  5. 5 Scrunch 9.5 of 16 Monitoring for larger teams; Gemini, Claude and AI Mode on Enterprise only.
  6. 6 Profound 8 of 16 Enterprise analytics; several engines and pricing behind a sales conversation.

Table

16 criteria, 4 groups, every cell sourced.

Columns follow the final ranking. "Yes" means the vendor states the feature on its public site on the check date, "partial" means limited or available only on a specific plan, "no" means it is not stated. Notes under a score explain the limit.

Criterion Humanswith.aiAthenaHQOtterly.AIPeec AIScrunchProfound
AI engine coverage
ChatGPT yes yes yes yes yes yes
Gemini yes yes yes yes partial Enterprise only yes
Perplexity yes yes yes yes yes partial Enterprise only
Claude partial custom plan yes yes partial Enterprise only partial Enterprise only partial Enterprise only
Microsoft Copilot yes yes yes partial Bing AI Mode yes partial Enterprise only
Google AI Overviews yes yes yes yes yes yes
Google AI Mode yes yes yes yes partial Enterprise only partial Enterprise only
Subtotal: AI engine coverage 6.5 / 77 / 77 / 76 / 75.5 / 75 / 7
Measurement
Visibility, position and share of voice yes yes yes yes yes yes
Multi-turn buyer dialogs (5 turns: reviews → proof → budget → risk → decision) yes Conversation Gauntlet no no no no no
Subtotal: Measurement 2 / 21 / 21 / 21 / 21 / 21 / 2
From data to results
Recommendations to grow visibility yes yes yes yes yes yes
Content drafting yes partial content optimization agent no audits, no article writing partial agent actions, not articles yes yes
Done-for-you articles: edited, fact-checked, with tables and Schema.org yes 1–40 articles a month no no no no no
Publishing to your site and external platforms yes no no no no no
Launching ads inside AI answers (ChatGPT Ads, Copilot) yes no no no ads library monitors others no no
Subtotal: From data to results 5 / 51.5 / 51 / 51.5 / 52 / 52 / 5
Terms
Prices published yes yes yes yes yes no custom enterprise pricing
A team runs the work for you yes no no no no no
Subtotal: Terms 2 / 21 / 21 / 21 / 21 / 20 / 2
Total points 15.5 / 1610.5 / 1610 / 169.5 / 169.5 / 168 / 16

Method

How points are counted and why these criteria.

Each criterion gives 1 point when the feature is available, 0.5 when it is limited or tied to a specific plan, and 0 when it is not stated. Points add up inside each group, and the total is the sum of the four groups. Groups carry no extra weight: a group with more criteria counts for more only because it has more checkable features.

The four groups are AI engine coverage, measurement, the path from data to results, and terms. Monitoring criteria follow the scored format popularized by public GEO ratings. We added the criteria that decide whether a brand gets customers rather than a report: the five-turn buyer conversation, finished articles, publishing, ads inside AI answers, and a team that runs the work.

If a criterion could not be sourced for every vendor, we dropped the row instead of guessing. Found a wrong score? Write to [email protected] and we will correct it with a date.

Sources for competitor scores:


FAQ

GEO platform rating — common questions.

What is the best GEO platform in 2026?

On the sum of 16 criteria, Humanswith.ai (15.5 points), then AthenaHQ (10.5) and Otterly.AI (10). If you only need monitoring, most tools in this rating cover the main engines; the difference is what happens after the report.

What is the difference between an AI visibility tracker and a full-cycle GEO platform?

A tracker shows whether AI engines mention your brand and which sources they cite. A full-cycle platform also does the work that changes the answer: articles for real buyer questions, publishing on the sites AI engines cite, and a re-scan to measure the effect.

Why test a five-turn buyer conversation?

Buyers rarely ask once. They follow up on reviews, proof, budget, risk and the final pick. A brand can appear in the first answer and disappear by the fifth. Humanswith.ai checks all five turns and shows where and to whom you lose.

Why does Humanswith.ai rate itself?

Most vendor ratings do. We say so up front, publish the method and a source for every competitor score, and keep our own gaps in the table. Any cell can be checked against the links in the Method section.


See who AI engines recommend instead of you.

In 30 minutes we map your buyer questions across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Mode and tell you honestly whether a tracker is enough or you need the full cycle.