Buyer's guide · choosing a vendor

How to choose a GEO or AEO agency without paying for renamed SEO.

Judge the vendor on evidence you can check: a case with a dated baseline and a re-measurement on the same prompts, the AI engines it measures by name, mentions reported apart from citations, a published monthly price, and a written plan for the month the numbers do not move.

GEO is a new category, and many vendors moved classic SEO retainers under the new name without changing the work. The result is a contract for "AI visibility" that never touches the answer layer. This guide lists what a serious vendor does, the promises that should end the call, what the market charges, and five questions to ask before you sign.

We sell in this category, so read our answers at the end as one vendor's answers, and hold us to the same five questions.


What a serious vendor does

Three things you can check before the first invoice.


Measures per engine

Your share of answers, against named competitors

The same prompt set run on a fixed cadence across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot and Google's AI answers, with each engine reported on its own line and your share set against the competitors buyers actually compare you with.

Produces citable pages

Content an engine can quote

Pages that answer one buyer question directly, carry checked numbers with their sources, and ship with structured data. Volume is not the measure; whether the next scan cites the page is.

Works beyond your site

The sources engines already trust

AI answers are assembled from review sites, listicles, communities and industry publications as much as from your own domain. A vendor who only edits your website leaves most of the answer to someone else.


Red flags

Promises that should end the call.

A guaranteed rank, or "number one in ChatGPT". Nobody controls AI answers directly. What a vendor controls is the evidence and the pages engines read.

"We will make you visible" with no measurement. Without per-engine numbers and a share against named competitors there is no way to tell whether anything changed.

Work that stops at your website. If the plan has no line for review platforms, listicles or communities, half of the answer stays out of reach.

A long contract before a baseline. Six or twelve months committed before you have seen where you stand today means you are paying for the pitch.


What it costs

Three ways to buy it, at three price levels.


AI visibility tool

$29–$2,250 a month

Measures well. Writing, publishing and site fixes stay with your team, and extra engines or prompts are add-ons.

Six platforms compared →

GEO / AEO agency

$4,500–$11,000 a month

The mid-market band across 1,146 agency quotes in October 2026: median $7,400, $8,640 for B2B SaaS, usually a six-month minimum. Only 23% of agencies publish a price.

Who owns which handoff →

Humanswith.ai

$149–$4,977 a month

The scan, gap list, articles, site fixes and re-scan run in your workspace and your marketer approves each step. Month-to-month, prices on the page.

See the plans →

Where the outside numbers come from: tool prices from the vendors' own pricing pages, read on 7 September 2026, and Profound's $2,250 quote for 600 prompts given to one of our clients; agency band from First Page Sage's GEO agency pricing survey of 7 October 2026 (1,146 quotes from 214 agencies).


Before you sign

Five questions that sort evidence from sales copy.

  1. Show me a case with before and after numbers. A dated baseline, the same prompts re-run later, and the count of answers that cite the client. "We became visible" without a baseline proves nothing.
  2. Which engines do you measure, by name? ChatGPT alone is not the market. Ask for the full list and whether each engine is measured on every scan or only some of them.
  3. Do you separate a mention from a citation? An engine naming you and an engine linking to your page are different results. A vendor who reports one number for both is hiding which one moved.
  4. What do you charge, and for how long am I committed? Ask for the monthly figure, what it meters (prompts, engines, articles) and the minimum term before you get on a second call.
  5. What happens if the numbers do not move? A serious vendor answers with a written correction plan and a refund or exit clause, not with a new promise.

One vague answer tells you little. Two in a row is enough to leave. A vendor that measures honestly answers all five with numbers.


Our answers to the same five

Hold us to the same test.

  1. Cases with before and after. Each client's price, timeframe and before → after numbers sit in one table. Birdview PSA, a B2B SaaS company in the 🇺🇸 US and 🇨🇦 Canada, went from 0.9% to 21.5% of ChatGPT answers in eight weeks.
  2. Engines by name. ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot, Google AIO and Google AI Mode; which ones a plan covers is written on the plan.
  3. Mentions apart from citations. Every scan reports both, per engine, and the share against the competitors you name.
  4. Price and term. $149–$4,977 a month, month-to-month, with prompts, engines and articles per plan on the pricing page.
  5. When numbers do not move. A 14-day refund on Starter and Growth if the first scan finds no closeable gap in your category; on Scale and Outlier, unused months refunded minus completed work.

FAQ

Choosing a GEO agency — common questions.

How do I choose a GEO or AEO agency?

Judge it on evidence you can check. Ask for a case with a dated baseline and a re-measurement on the same prompts, the list of AI engines it measures by name, whether it reports mentions and citations separately, its monthly price and minimum term, and what it does if the numbers do not move. A vendor who answers all five with numbers is worth a second call.

What does a GEO agency cost?

In First Page Sage's October 2026 survey of 1,146 quotes from 214 agencies, the mid-market retainer ran $4,500 to $11,000 a month, median $7,400, usually with a six-month minimum; B2B SaaS came in at a median of $8,640. Only 23% of the agencies publish a price at all.

Which promises should make me walk away?

A guaranteed rank or "number one in ChatGPT", visibility claims with no per-engine measurement, work that stops at your own website, and a long contract before you have seen a baseline. Nobody controls AI answers directly; what a vendor can control is the evidence and pages engines read.

Agency, software tool, or a platform that does the work?

A tool measures and leaves writing, publishing and site fixes to your team. An agency does the work on its own tooling and cadence. A workspace like ours runs the scan, the gap list, the articles, the site fixes and the re-scan, and your marketer approves each step. Pick by who will do the work on your side, not by the label.

How long before a GEO agency shows results?

Ask for the first measurement within days, not weeks. In our Birdview PSA case the share of ChatGPT answers naming the client went from 0.9% to 21.5% in eight weeks after eight articles. Any vendor should be able to show you a case with a timeframe like that, or say plainly that it has none yet.


Start with one request: show me the measurement.

A 30-minute call that starts with your audit, not our deck.

You arrive to a per-engine citation map of your category and the gaps worth closing first, before anyone talks about a contract.